> General Discussions

Defining evil?

<< < (3/4) > >>

StevenL:

--- Quote from: Porter on February 01, 2017, 05:19:41 PM ---Hi StevenL, and welcome to the forum :)

I guess it depends on who created the "particular occurrence" right? God did say in Genesis that everything He created was good, which includes evil, but that's only because of the benevolent purpose for which He created it for. If men do evil I can't see how that could ever possibly be for a good intention. God means it for good, but man doesn't and is incapable of using evil for a good purpose like God.

--- End quote ---

Hi Porter! Thanks for the welcome.

Since, according to Ray, God creates/causes Every particular occurrence and thought, then I would also have to suppose that man's intent or will doesn't enter into the equation. I can't really know. I suppose it's hard for me to cut through sometime and 'define' these things since many of the 'definitions' of good or evil were kinda defined for me by society and church/religion. My preacher said it's evil to "...drink, smoke, cuss, chew, and go with girls that do". Some things that are 'evil' in my society are 'good' in, say, Sudan or Bangladesh. I may do something 'good' there and get stoned for it. But I think all of us with the Spirit pretty much 'know' evil when we see it, even without a specific definition. Like Dave posted, we're supposed to know good and evil more clearly as we use our spiritual senses. And if we are to judge ourselves, it would really behoove us to know well lest we judge ourselves falsely. I've seen a lot of what I thought was 'good' turn out to be 'evil... and vice versa. Heck, many many people think that messenger of 'light' in the temple of God is 'good' but it is most surely 'evil'. But it is God's will that the masquerader is there, so it's 'good'. So any true 'definition' of evil can only come from the Mind of Christ.

I've pondered this recently also, regarding evil: Evil entered the world in the garden through the first adam. The knowledge of good and evil was already contained in the 'tree' before anybody here ever DID any evil. So what form did 'evil' take before mankind partook of it? Was it something manifested among the angels/messengers? Since the Adversary sinned 'from the beginning', was evil created along with his creation or was it already there before? Dadburn it! Where'd this evil come from? I sure didn't want it from my beginning but I darn sure had it.  :-\   Not calling for answers or replies, just saying some of my musings.

Working on part 4 of the myth of free will letters again. Maybe I'll get it all this time.   :)

Porter:
This thread has been quite the eye opener for me, thanks all. One thing that is really sticking out for me more then anything is that most of humanity (including myself) does not know what is good or bad. Not talking about the obvious forms of good and bad, but the good and bad God wants us to see and understand; what ever that may be.

A few in this age are having their eyes opened like Adam and Eve had their eyes opened after they ate of the tree. They were always, from the start miserable, wretched, poor, naked and blind, but they just didn't know it till after they ate. God then judged them, sentenced (rewarded) them and then clothed them. Sounds very familiar Dave.  8)

This all makes me think this "event" in Genesis didn't all happen in one single day, but rather over a period of time as most things do in Genesis. And as Ray pointed out that time, circumstance and contrast is what is needed to gain a good working knowledge of good and evil.

Notice how God told Adam that he would continue to eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil for the rest of his life.

Gen 3:17  And He said to Adam, "Because you listened to your wife's voice and ate from the tree about which I commanded you, 'Do not eat from it': The ground is cursed because of you. You will eat from it by means of painful labor all the days of your life.

Anyway I just thought that was interesting.

By the way Steven, and you may already know this and I'm just misunderstanding, but Adam and Eve sinned before they ate of the tree as Ray explained from his papers. If sinning is bad/evil, then isn't it logical to conclude that bad/evil was always within them? The creature was after all created in futility and with an heart too weak to resist sin. Not saying you are wrong, it's just that this is kinda tough to wrap my head around, hence the question.

Like you this is just mostly my musings, but feel free to chime in. We are after all here to discuss what we've learned at BT to hopefully get a better understanding. ;) Lord knows I always need more. Understanding is awesome, especially understanding good and bad. :D

StevenL:

--- Quote from: Porter on February 03, 2017, 01:24:21 AM ---
By the way Steven, and you may already know this and I'm just misunderstanding, but Adam and Eve sinned before they ate of the tree as Ray explained from his papers. If sinning is bad/evil, then isn't it logical to conclude that bad/evil was always within them? The creature was after all created in futility and with an heart too weak to resist sin. Not saying you are wrong, it's just that this is kinda tough to wrap my head around, hence the question.

Like you this is just mostly my musings, but feel free to chime in. We are after all here to discuss what we've learned at BT to hopefully get a better understanding. ;) Lord knows I always need more. Understanding is awesome, especially understanding good and bad. :D

--- End quote ---

I was mainly musing about the existence of evil before adam was formed and placed in the garden. I did read where Ray said Eve sinned before she 'ate', since the coveting took place in her heart. But the coveting didn't enter until she was presented with the beguiling (as far as I know) so ... I don't know whether evil was present with them all along. Seems to me ? they were previously just Ignorant, without knowledge, and completely vulnerable to an outside 'cause' or beguiling, which God provided via the serpent. But I think Ray said that they weren't created evil, they were created weak and unable to resist or combat evil. So when evil presented itself, they were goners.  Ecc 7:29  See, I found this alone: That the One, Elohim, made humanity upright, Yet they seek many devisings."

My main thought was that before the 'eating', before the coveting, the tree already contained the knowledge of evil, so it existed somewhere. It apparently existed in the serpent, from 'the beginning', whenever that was. Then..."And saying is Yahweh Elohim, "Behold! The human becomes as one of us, knowing good and evil". So the 'us' already knew evil. From whence? We may never know. Maybe He'll tell us one day when we become like Him. 

Ecc 8:16  When I applied my heart to know wisdom, And to see the experience that is appointed on earth (For both by day and night, there is no seeing of sleep for Him with His eyes), Ecc 8:17  Then I saw in all the work of the One, Elohim, That a man is not able to find out the work that is done under the sun, Forasmuch as a man may toil in seeking it out but shall not find it; And even if a wise man says he knows, he is not able to find it out."

Yeah, I want all the understanding I can get too! There's nothing like glimpses of the Holy.

StevenL:
BTW, you or anybody else here can say I'm wrong anytime you like. I'm not easily offended and if I'm wrong, I'm wrong. I want to KNOW when I'm wrong but I want proof of said evil.   ;D   But I also learned long ago that I'm not necessarily wrong just because someone says I am.

I want to be washed with the Water of His Word. Some of that Water comes through Members of the Body through gifts. We're supposed to be always sharing Food and Drink together.

indianabob:
Hi Steven,

As an aside, I was given to understand that Adam's and Eve's choice was to decide for themselves what was good or bad, rather than to ask God and then obey God's instructions. God told them to "not eat the fruit of or even touch the tree in the midst of the garden, lest you die", Gen 2:17 and 3:3.
So the coveting was first then the action, but they didn't know evil before they choose to decide for themselves to take of that fruit, did they?

Indiana Bob

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page