Jeff, Here is a quote that I found on the web. Please find what is wrong with the logic.
Indiana bob
"This is not complicated, but it is hard, in the sense that truth is often hard.
.
Christ is the best and highest example of Christianity. Christ committed no sin, and He taught no sin.
No one can reject Christ or His teaching or His deeds and still be a Christian.
It is NOT possible.
.
Mohamad is the best and highest example of Islam. Mohamad committed great sin, he was a mass-murderer, and he taught mass-murder.
No one can reject Mohamad or his teaching or his deeds and still be a Muslim.
It is NOT possible.
.
It is not possible to accept and embrace the teachings and deeds of a mass-murderer and be a good person.
It is NOT possible.
.
If it is not possible for a Muslim to reject Mohamad and his atrocities, then how is it possible for a Muslim to be a good person?
.
I have presented this practical dilemma to several Muslims over the last couple of weeks, and so far, not one has had a word in response.
If anyone knows how to answer in any way besides the obvious, I would like to know."